19. • Open Public HearingCity of Sherman (Grayson County)

430 EAST BROCKETT STREET (Project No. 000430-2026) The request of Jason Earnhart (Owner), Brandon Gumaer (Applicant) and Copley Land Surveying (Surveyor) concerning the property located at 430 East Brockett Street, consisting of 0.310 acres, being Lot 1, Block 7 in the J.B. McAnair Survey, Abstract No. 763, as follows: Planning and Zoning Commission

Presented in: City of Sherman Planning and Zoning Commission and Board of Adjustment Meeting on 2026-07-21

Official Roll-Call Vote

Expands Gov't • 6.8/10 Impact Weight

PASSED (7 - 0)

“Motion to approve 430 EAST BROCKETT STREET (Project No. 000430-2026) The request of Jason Earnhart (Owner), Brandon Gumaer (Applicant) and Copley Land Surveying (Surveyor) concerning the property located at 430 East Brockett Street, consisting of 0.310 acres, being Lot 1, Block 7 in the J.B. McAnair Survey, Abstract No. 763, as follows: Planning and Zoning Commission”

Shawn Teamann

Mayor (At-Large)

YES

Clay Barnett

Councilmember, District 1 (District 1)

YES

Josh Stevenson

Councilmember, District 2 (District 2)

YES

Pamela Howeth

Councilmember, District 3 (District 3)

YES

Daron Holland

Councilmember, District 4 (District 4)

YES

Henry Marroquin

Councilmember, At-Large Place 1 (At-Large Place 1)

YES

Juston Dobbs

Councilmember, At-Large Place 2 (At-Large Place 2)

YES

Staff Report & Agenda Item Details

430 EAST BROCKETT STREET (Project No. 000430-2026) The request of Jason Earnhart (Owner), Brandon Gumaer (Applicant) and Copley Land Surveying (Surveyor) concerning the property located at 430 East Brockett Street, consisting of 0.310 acres, being Lot 1, Block 7 in the J.B. McAnair Survey, Abstract No. 763, as follows: Planning and Zoning Commission Public Hearing, Site Plan and Specific Use Permit under Section 14.06.009 to allow an Automobile repair, body work, or painting in a C-2 (General Commercial) District/College Park Overlay District.

Bastiat Liberty & Property Rights Analysis

This motion is scored as EXPANDS_GOVERNMENT (Impact Weight: 6.8/10). Under the Bastiat Liberty Watchdog Index, measures that increase tax rates or fee schedules, issue new debt or Certificates of Obligation, expand regulatory/zoning restrictions on private land use, or authorize unbudgeted spending expansions reduce an official's Freedom Score when voted YES (and reward dissenting NO votes).