Back to Docket Search
30 • Action ItemsCARTHAGE ISD (Panola County)
Review and Consider Approval of Resolution to Declare a Good Cause Exception for House Bill 3
Presented in: CARTHAGE ISD Board of Trustees Regular Meeting on 2026-07-20
Official Roll-Call Vote
Restrains Gov't • 2.0/10 Impact Weight
PASSED (7 - 0)
“Action on Review and Consider Approval of Resolution to Declare a Good Cause Exception for House Bill 3”
BG
Brenda Giles
Trustee, Place 5 (Place 5)
YES
EH
Elzie Hicks
Trustee, Place 6 (Place 6)
YES
TS
Truman Shirey
Trustee, Place 7 (Place 7)
YES
DB
Dr Ben Donald
Trustee, Place 1 (Place 1)
YES
FW
Frank Willis
Trustee, Place 2 (Place 2)
YES
MS
Mary Sherman
Trustee, Place 3 (Place 3)
YES
PB
Paul Beatty
Trustee, Place 4 (Place 4)
YES
Staff Report & Agenda Item Details
Review and Consider Approval of Resolution to Declare a Good Cause Exception for House Bill 3
Bastiat Liberty & Property Rights Analysis
This motion is scored as RESTRAINS_GOVERNMENT (Impact Weight: 2.0/10). Under the Bastiat Liberty Watchdog Index, voting YES on measures that cap or reduce ad valorem tax burdens, expand taxpayer exemptions, retire debt early, enforce competitive bidding caps, or remove regulatory/zoning barriers to private property rights earns a positive Pro-Liberty score.